How AI Search Changes The Way Customers Find Local Businesses

A customer with a leaking water heater used to type a search, scan blue links, and click one. Now the search page often answers the question first. A short AI-written summary sits at the top, above the links, and many customers never click anything at all.

That changes the job of a local business website. Ranking well is no longer enough. The page has to be one the AI summary draws from, and the one that earns the call when a customer does click.

The short answer: AI search adds an AI-written summary to the top of Google results, using indexed pages eligible to appear in Search. Fewer people click through, so local businesses need clear answers on their pages, a complete Google Business Profile, and strong reviews from real customers.

TL;DR

• AI summaries now sit above the normal results on many Google searches and answer the question on the page.
• Clicks fall where a summary appears: Pew found users clicked a result on 8% of visits with a summary, against 15% without one.
• Local, urgent searches still produce calls.

What Is AI Search, And How Is It Different?

AI search means Google, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and similar tools answer a question in their own words, using pages from the web. On Google, the feature is called an AI Overview. It appears at the top of the results page, above the normal links.

The old search gave you a list of links. AI search gives you the answer first, and the links second. For a simple question, such as "why is my furnace making noise", the summary may be enough. For "plumber near me open now", the customer still has to pick a business and call.

Google has said that optimizing for AI search is still SEO. For supporting links, a page must be indexed and eligible to appear in Search with a snippet. Google describes this in its AI features guidance. There is no special file or trick that puts a page into the summary. Google's own guide to succeeding in AI search says unique, genuinely useful content matters more than any technical shortcut.

What Do The Numbers Actually Say?

Pew Research Center studied the real Google searches of 900 US adults during March 2025, a total of 68,879 searches. About one search in five produced an AI summary. When a summary appeared, users clicked a search result on 8% of visits, against 15% when no summary appeared. Only 1% clicked a link inside the summary itself, and 26% of visits ended the session, against 16% without one. Longer and question searches produce summaries far more often: 60% of searches starting with who, what, when, or why produced one, against 8% of one- or two-word searches. The full study is published by Pew Research Center.

An Ahrefs study published in February 2026 compared 300,000 keywords and estimated a 58% lower position-one click-through rate for queries with AI Overviews against its modeled comparison. This is a study result, not a forecast for an individual local business.

Read both studies the same way. They show the same direction: fewer clicks, more answers on the page. They do not say search is dead. They say the clicks that remain go to pages and businesses that are easy to trust and easy to contact.

Why Do Fewer Clicks Matter For A Local Business?

A local service business lives on calls and booked jobs, not page views. A drop in clicks hurts only if it also drops calls.

General questions lose the most clicks. Someone asking how a furnace works can get the answer from the summary and stop. That visitor was never going to call today. But a customer with a broken furnace at night wants a name, a phone number, and proof the business is open. The summary cannot fix their furnace. It can only point them to someone who can.

The risk is different. If your business is invisible in the summary and in the links below it, the customer never learns your name. If your profile is thin, your reviews are few, or your website gives no direct answer, the AI has nothing clear to quote and the customer has no reason to pick you.

What Still Brings In Calls?

Four things still bring in calls, and none of them are new.

First, local intent. Searches with a place, a service, and words like "near me", "open now", or "emergency" come from people who need a business today. Those searches still end in calls.

Second, a complete Google Business Profile. When a customer searches for a plumber nearby, they compare hours, phone number, reviews, photos, and distance. Keep it accurate and active. Our guide to what a Google Business Profile is walks through the setup.

Third, reviews. Reviews are the proof a summary cannot invent. Ask every customer, reply to every review, and never pay for one.

Fourth, a website that answers directly. A service page that opens with a plain answer, lists what is included, shows real work, and puts the phone number where it can be tapped will earn the clicks that remain.

How Should A Local Business Website Change For AI Search?

Change the writing first, not the technology. Write each page so a person and an AI system can both pull the answer out of it.

Start each section with a direct answer in two or three sentences, then add the detail below. Use headings written as the customer's questions: "How much does it cost?", "How long does it take?", "What is included?"

Keep facts visible on the page. Prices, hours, service areas, and process steps should appear in the normal text, not hidden in code or images. If the fact is not in the text, the summary cannot use it.

Use tables where a comparison helps. A short table that compares two or three service options is easy for a reader to scan and easy for a system to lift. Keep it honest and keep the numbers real.

Add a short FAQ at the end of each service page: three to five questions in the customer's words, answers of 40 to 60 words each. That section catches the follow-up questions the main page does not cover.

Finally, keep the business details identical everywhere: the same name, phone number, address, hours, and services on your website, your Google Business Profile, and your social pages. When they conflict, trust drops.

What Should You Stop Doing?

Stop writing pages for search engines first. Google's guidance on helpful content lists the warning signs: lots of topics hoping some of them rank, pages written only because a topic is trending, summaries of other sites with nothing added, and writing to a word count. All of that now fails faster, because the AI summary will simply use a better page instead.

Stop chasing tricks that promise AI citations. There is no special schema, no llms.txt file, and no hidden markup that guarantees a citation. Google says there is no special structured data requirement for AI Overviews or AI Mode. Spend the time on the content instead.

Avoid producing many near-identical pages mainly to manipulate rankings. Google’s scaled-content abuse policy concerns this purpose and lack of added value, not a fixed page count. One good page per question beats ten thin pages.

Stop hiding behind vague claims. "Trusted by many" and "high quality service" say nothing. A real photo, a real review, a real price, or a named process says something.

What Does This Mean For Your Marketing Plan?

Do not panic, and do not rebuild everything. The plan stays the same at its core: be findable, be clear, and be easy to call.

Spend your effort in this order. First, fix your Google Business Profile and your top service pages. Second, make each service page answer its main question directly, with a short FAQ and a visible number. Third, collect reviews steadily and reply to them. Fourth, measure calls and bookings, not page views.

Paid ads and social media still have a role, but they are separate channels. Our Google Ads service and our social media service each reach people the search page does not.

Expect the ground to keep moving. Google changes how summaries appear and how often they show links. The habit that survives every change is the same one that worked before AI search: publish true, useful pages, keep your details accurate, and make it easy for a customer to reach you.

Key Takeaways

• AI summaries answer questions on the results page, and clicks fall where they appear: Pew found 8% against 15%.
• Local, urgent searches still produce calls.
• Write pages with answers first and a short FAQ.
• Keep your profile complete, reviews strong, and details identical everywhere.
• Measure calls and bookings, not page views.

Book A Free Discovery Call

Book a free discovery call with Nextalytic. We will look at your website, your Google Business Profile, and your local visibility, and tell you what needs fixing.

Call (302) 360-6373 or email contact@nextalytic.com.

Book a free discovery call ↗ · Send an inquiry

Frequently Asked Questions

Will AI search replace Google results?

No. AI summaries sit above the normal results, with the links below them. The customer can still click through when they need a business rather than an answer.

Can a small business appear in an AI summary?

Yes. A supporting link can come from an indexed page eligible to appear in Search with a snippet, and a small business page that answers a question directly can be one of them. There is no size requirement, and no special markup guarantees it.

Should I still invest in SEO if clicks are falling?

Yes, but judge it by calls and bookings, not by page views. SEO puts your pages, your profile, and your reviews in front of customers who need a service now.

Does my Google Business Profile matter more now?

Yes. When fewer people click through to websites, the profile carries more of the decision. Hours, phone number, reviews, and photos are often all a customer sees before they call.

How do I know if AI search is affecting my business?

Look at Search Console for impressions and clicks, and look at your call log for booked jobs. If impressions hold steady while clicks fall, investigate search features, rankings, query mix and seasonality. That pattern alone does not establish that AI summaries caused the change.